Island
Hopper
GUIDES

Hawaii’s Top-Rated Restaurants: Critics’ Choice & Local Favorites

Hawaii offers a dining scene as diverse and vibrant as its landscapes. From elegant fine dining establishments to hole-in-the-wall local joints serving up plate lunches, the islands cater to every palate and budget. This article explores a curated selection of Hawaii’s top-rated restaurants, blending critics’ choice awards with beloved local favorites to give you an insider’s guide to the best culinary experiences the Aloha State has to offer.

Oahu’s Culinary Gems: A Taste of Paradise

Oahu, the most populous island, is a melting pot of flavors. In Honolulu, you’ll find world-class chefs pushing boundaries, while in other parts of the island, you’ll discover authentic Hawaiian and Asian cuisine perfected over generations. Cost estimates are relative, with “$” being budget-friendly, “$$” moderate, and “$$$” expensive. Note that pricing can vary based on menu selection and seasonal ingredient availability.

Fine Dining Experiences: A True Indulgence

For an unforgettable evening, consider La Mer at Halekulani ($$$), consistently ranked among the best restaurants in the United States. Located in Waikiki, La Mer boasts stunning ocean views and an exquisite French-influenced menu. Expect impeccable service and a romantic ambiance. Reservations are essential, and a dress code is enforced. One dish that often receives high praise is their signature soufflé. To reach the Halekulani, which houses La Mer, you can easily use ride-sharing services, taxis, or personal vehicles; parking is available, but can be limited. Alternatively, many hotels in Waikiki are within walking distance.

Another standout is Chef Mavro ($$$), also in Honolulu, offering innovative and contemporary Hawaiian cuisine. Chef Mavro’s tasting menus are a culinary journey, highlighting local ingredients and showcasing the chef’s artistry. The wine pairings are exceptional. Be sure to book well in advance. Driving directions will take you to Ala Moana Boulevard, where it is easily accessible. Valet parking is usually provided. If you prefer to pair your own wines, their cellar is quite impressive!

Local Flavors and Plate Lunches: A Taste of Aloha

To experience the true essence of Hawaiian food, head to Helena’s Hawaiian Food ($), a no-frills institution in Honolulu. Their kalua pig (slow-roasted pork) and pipikaula (dried beef) are legendary. Be prepared for a wait, but the authentic flavors are worth it. Helena’s is located off the beaten path, so a GPS-enabled device would be very beneficial when coming here. Consider taking an Uber or Lyft to avoid any parking issues.

For the quintessential plate lunch, try Rainbow Drive-In ($). With multiple locations on Oahu, they offer generous portions of classic Hawaiian comfort food, like mixed plates with teriyaki beef, chicken katsu, and macaroni salad. A perfect quick and budget-friendly meal. Many locals opt to pick up a plate lunch from Rainbow Drive-In on the way to enjoy a relaxing day at Ala Moana Beach park.

Asian Influences: A Fusion of Tastes

Hawaii’s diverse culture is reflected in its cuisine, particularly in its Asian influences. Musubi Cafe Iyasume ($) in Waikiki is a must-try for onigiri (rice balls) in myriad flavors. It’s a perfect snack or light meal. Expect long lines, especially during peak hours. Be sure to arrive early to secure your favorite flavors, as they often sell out. The cafe is within walking distance of most Waikiki hotels.

For amazing ramen, check out Marukame Udon ($), with several locations on Oahu. The freshly made noodles and flavorful broths are a crowd-pleaser. It’s also an excellent value. You can customize your bowl with tempura and other toppings for a truly unique experience. The Waikiki location is particularly popular, leading to substantial wait times; plan accordingly. The ordering system is a cafeteria-style setup which moves along rapidly.

Maui’s Gastronomic Delights: From Farm to Table

Maui, known as the “Valley Isle,” boasts a thriving agricultural scene, which translates into fresh, locally sourced ingredients in its restaurants. From upscale dining to casual eateries, Maui offers a diverse culinary landscape.

Upscale Dining with Ocean Views

Mama’s Fish House ($$$) in Paia is an iconic Maui restaurant known for its fresh seafood and stunning oceanfront location. The menu changes daily based on the catch of the day, ensuring a truly unique dining experience. Reservations are essential, often booked months in advance. This would be a great place to celebrate a honeymoon or anniversary! Mama’s Fish House is located along the Hana Highway (Highway 360), so consider allowing ample time to enjoy the scenic ride.

Merriman’s Kapalua ($$$) offers breathtaking sunset views and a menu that emphasizes locally sourced ingredients. The atmosphere is sophisticated yet relaxed, making it perfect for a special occasion. The restaurant’s commitment to sustainability is commendable. Be sure to try any of their fresh seafood or farm-to-table items. Located in the Kapalua Resort, parking is readily available, and you might want to factor in time to explore the stunning cliffs of the resort.

Casual Eats and Local Hangouts

For a more casual dining experience, head to Star Noodle ($$) in Lahaina. This modern Asian-inspired restaurant offers a diverse menu of noodle dishes, salads, and small plates. Share a few dishes with friends to sample the variety. The lahaina fried soup is a signature item. It’s a well known spot with wait times that can be long! Make sure you make a restaurant reservation online. There are also some nearby cafes close by if you choose to have a coffee and pastry before or after your meal.

Try Paia Fish Market ($$) for fresh and affordable seafood. With multiple locations on Maui, this casual eatery is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The fish tacos are a must-try. This is a no-frills establishment, with an emphasis on fast service and great food. It’s perfect for a quick lunch or a casual dinner.

Sweet Treats and Refreshments

Beat the Maui heat with a visit to Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice ($). With multiple locations, Ululani’s offers a wide array of flavors and toppings, ensuring a refreshing treat. The shave ice is incredibly fine and flavorful. They make their own fresh syrups in-house using cane sugar.

For a taste of local coffee, visit Maui Coffee Roasters ($$). They offer a wide variety of coffee beans and brewing methods, and their knowledgeable staff can help you find the perfect cup. It’s the perfect place to start your day or enjoy an afternoon pick-me-up. They also offer pastry items and breakfast sandwiches to accompany your coffee.

Big Island’s Culinary Adventures: From Volcano to Sea

The Big Island of Hawaii is a land of contrasts, from active volcanoes to lush rainforests. Its culinary scene reflects this diversity, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

Fine Dining with a Hawaiian Flair

Brown’s Beach House ($$$) at the Fairmont Orchid, Hawaii, offers a sophisticated dining experience with stunning ocean views. The menu features contemporary Hawaiian cuisine with a focus on fresh seafood and locally sourced produce. It’s a great spot for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. The restaurant focuses on utilizing ingredients that are found in the surrounding ocean. The Fairmont Orchid also has a well-known luau event you may consider attending during your stay.

Another option is CanoeHouse ($$$) at the Mauna Lani, Auberge Resorts Collection, offering a sophisticated setting with panoramic views of the Pacific Ocean. Their menu features modern Hawaiian cuisine with influences from around the world. The restaurant’s ambiance is elegant and refined. Sunset views here are simply stunning. Be sure to check their calendar in advance as they also host culinary events on certain evenings.

Casual and Local Eats

For a taste of local flavors, visit Pine Tree Cafe ($) in Kailua-Kona. This family-owned restaurant serves up delicious and affordable plate lunches, including kalua pig, teriyaki beef, and chicken katsu. Be sure to try their homemade macaroni salad. This is a popular spot for locals, and it’s a great place to experience the true taste of Hawaii.

Umeke’s Fish Market Bar & Grill ($$) in Kona offers fresh and flavorful poke bowls, plate lunches, and seafood dishes. Their poke is some of the best on the island. It’s a popular spot for lunch and dinner. You can also purchase fresh cuts of fish to enjoy at home.

Unique Culinary Experiences

No trip to the Big Island is complete without a visit to a coffee plantation. Kona Coffee Living History Farm ($) offers tours and tastings of their award-winning Kona coffee. Learn about the history of coffee farming in Kona and sample some of the finest coffee in the world. This would be a fun activity for both adults and children. Kona Coffee farms are usually along the slopes of the mountains; therefore, be prepared for some winding and hilly routes.

For a truly unique dining experience, consider a farm-to-table dinner at Hamakua Mushrooms ($$). They offer a variety of mushroom-based dishes, showcasing the versatility of this often-underestimated ingredient. The setting is rustic and beautiful, offering a glimpse into the Big Island’s agricultural landscape. The mushroom burgers are a crowd favorite!

Kauai’s Dining Scene: A Taste of the Garden Isle

Kauai, known as the “Garden Isle,” is a paradise of lush rainforests and stunning beaches. Its culinary scene reflects this natural beauty, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Kauai is known for its fresh seafood and tropical fruits.

Fine Dining with a View

The Beach House Restaurant ($$$) in Poipu offers breathtaking sunset views and a menu that features Pacific Rim cuisine. The restaurant’s elegant ambiance and stunning location make it perfect for a romantic dinner. Be sure to try their fresh seafood dishes. The restaurant’s open-air design allows you to enjoy the beautiful Kauai scenery. You might even catch a glimpse of a sea turtle swimming along the coastline!

Another option is Red Salt ($$$) at the Ko’a Kea Hotel & Resort, offering contemporary Hawaiian cuisine with a focus on fresh, local ingredients. The restaurant’s stylish decor and attentive service create a memorable dining experience. Red Salt is best known for its seafood and fresh fish options. The resort is close to Poipu Beach and other prominent attractions.

Casual and Local Favorites

For a casual and affordable meal, head to Pono Market ($) in Kapaa. This local institution serves up classic Hawaiian dishes, like laulau, kalua pig, and poi. It’s a great place to experience the authentic flavors of Kauai. Perfect for a quick picnic option!

Bubba’s Burgers ($), with multiple locations on Kauai, is a must-try for burger lovers. Their juicy burgers and crispy fries are a local favorite. Be sure to try their special sauce. This no-frills establishment is perfect if you are on a budget. It’s also family-friendly!

Food Trucks and Hidden Gems

Explore the many food trucks on Kauai for a taste of local culinary creativity. One standout is Hanalei Taro & Juice Co. ($$). Enjoy some of the authentic dishes made with taro. They serve a range of traditional Hawaiian dishes but they have smoothies and beverages using local fruits and vegetables.

Look for signs pointing to fish tacos at roadside stands. These gems are often the best and freshest seafood available on the island. While these stands might have limited menus, they are a place to find true local chefs and food enthusiasts. Prices at food trucks are typically budget-friendly.

General Tips for Dining in Hawaii

Dining in Hawaii can be a truly unforgettable experience. To make the most of your culinary adventure, here are a few tips to keep in mind:

Reservations: For fine dining restaurants and popular local spots, reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season. Book well in advance to avoid disappointment. Many high-end restaurants take reservations months in advance.
Embrace Local Flavors: Don’t be afraid to try new things! Hawaii’s culinary scene is diverse and exciting, so step outside your comfort zone and sample the local specialties.
Support Local Businesses: By dining at locally owned restaurants, you’re supporting the community and helping to preserve Hawaii’s unique culture. You’re also more likely to experience authentic, traditional cuisine.
Dress Code: While Hawaii is generally a casual place, some fine dining restaurants may have a dress code. Check the restaurant’s website or call ahead to inquire.
Tipping: Tipping is customary in Hawaii. A standard tip is 15-20% of the bill.
Respect the Culture: Show respect for Hawaiian culture and traditions by being mindful of your behavior and language. This includes understanding the history of Hawaiian food and learning a few basic Hawaiian phrases.
Happy Hour: Many restaurants offer daily happy hour specials with reduced prices on food and drinks. It is a great option for budget travelers. Happy hours are often very crowded, especially at popular spots.

FAQ Section

Here are some frequently asked questions about dining in Hawaii:

Are reservations really necessary?

Yes, especially for popular restaurants and fine dining establishments. Booking in advance is highly recommended, particularly during peak tourist seasons and holidays, to secure your desired dining time. During the shoulder season, reservations are still a good idea as you may compete with locals and other recurring visitors.

What is a typical budget for dining in Hawaii?

It varies widely. You can find delicious and affordable plate lunches for under $15, while fine dining experiences can easily cost over $100 per person, excluding drinks. Plan your budget accordingly, considering the type of restaurants you want to visit and the number of meals you plan to eat out. Be prepared for increased costs when dining in tourist areas such as Waikiki or resort vicinities.

What are some must-try Hawaiian dishes?

Kalua pig, poke, laulau, poi, and plate lunches are all essential Hawaiian culinary experiences. Don’t leave Hawaii without trying these dishes! Also, be sure to sample local fruits like pineapple, mango, and papaya. Haupia (coconut pudding) is also a great way to end the meal.

Are vegetarian and vegan options readily available?

Yes, most restaurants in Hawaii offer vegetarian and vegan options, though the selection can vary. Inquire with your server about modifications to accommodate dietary restrictions. You’re going to have a tougher time finding these options when seeking out authentic local spots.

How can I find the most authentic local restaurants?

Ask locals for recommendations, read online reviews from local food bloggers, and venture outside of tourist areas to discover hidden gems. Look for restaurants that are busy with local clientele, as this is often a sign of authentic and delicious food. Check out the local newspapers or websites to see reviews for restaurants not traditionally included in the travel magazines.

Is it safe to drink the tap water in Hawaii?

Yes, tap water is generally safe to drink in Hawaii. However, if you’re concerned about the taste or quality of the water, you can purchase bottled water or use a water filter.

References

  • Halekulani Official Website
  • Chef Mavro Official Website
  • Helena’s Hawaiian Food
  • Rainbow Drive-In
  • Musubi Cafe Iyasume
  • Marukame Udon Official Website
  • Mama’s Fish House Official Website
  • Merriman’s Kapalua Official Website
  • Star Noodle Official Website
  • Paia Fish Market Official Website
  • Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice Official Website
  • Maui Coffee Roasters Official Website
  • Brown’s Beach House at Fairmont Orchid Official Website
  • CanoeHouse at Mauna Lani Official Website
  • Pine Tree Cafe
  • Umeke’s Fish Market Bar & Grill
  • Kona Coffee Living History Farm
  • Hamakua Mushrooms
  • The Beach House Restaurant Official Website
  • Red Salt at Ko’a Kea Hotel & Resort
  • Pono Market
  • Bubba’s Burgers
  • Hanalei Taro & Juice Co.

Ready to embark on your culinary adventure in Hawaii? Don’t just dream about the flavors of paradise; start planning your trip today! Explore the options, book those reservations, and prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable journey. Aloha and happy eating!

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Emily Carter

I’m Emily Carter, a travel writer who’s on the road most of the year—sometimes with my husband Michael and our kids, Lily and Ethan, and other times traveling solo so I can focus closely on one place. When you travel with me through my writing, you’ll notice I move slowly, walking local streets, stopping at markets, and paying attention to how a place really feels once you’re there.When I’m traveling with my family, I’m always thinking about what will work well for you if you have kids, and what often gets overlooked. When I’m on my own, I spend more time in neighborhoods, along coastal paths, or in historic areas where daily life unfolds naturally. I focus on practical details, everyday food, and real experiences, so you know what you’ll actually see, hear, and experience when you arrive.

And oh, I may earn a small commission from affiliate links, which helps support the site at no extra cost to you. Thanks for the support!

Leave a Reply

Readers'
Top Picks

Coconut Shrimp: A Must-Try Dish When Dining In Hawaii

Coconut shrimp is an absolute must-try when you’re soaking up the sun in Hawaii. This delectable dish features succulent shrimp coated in crispy coconut flakes, offering a tropical explosion with every bite that perfectly complements the island’s laid-back atmosphere. Whether you’re watching a breathtaking sunset on the beach, or

Read More »

Beyond Pineapple: Exploring Hawaii’s Unique Fruits & Vegetables

Forget the pineapple-centric postcards! Hawaii’s culinary landscape bursts with a vibrant array of fruits and vegetables far beyond the spiky, golden treat. Exploring these unique offerings unveils a richer, more authentic dining experience, revealing a deeper connection to the islands’ land and culture. This guide dives into the delicious

Read More »

Tasting Hawaii’s Regional Specialties: A Culinary Road Trip

Forget luaus with predictable spreads. Let’s embark on a real Hawaiian culinary road trip, ditching the tourist traps and diving headfirst into the regional specialties that make each island taste distinctly different. We’re talking about the food the locals rave about, the dishes passed down through generations – the

Read More »