Lost Riches: Discover Sunken Treasure Locations In The British Virgin Islands

In 1750, pirates made off with 55 chests of silver coins from a Spanish galleon, and most of that loot has never been found. The British Virgin Islands still hold millions of dollars in buried treasure, scattered across islands that are now popular sailing and snorkeling destinations. If your family has ever wondered what it feels like to follow a real pirate trail, this guide lays out the key spots where history and legend overlap — and what you can actually do there today with kids in tow.

The table below gives you a quick look at the four main treasure-linked spots in the BVI and what each offers. Use it to decide which ones fit your trip.

Norman Island: The Real Treasure Island

Every treasure hunt in the BVI starts here. Norman Island sits at the southern tip of the British Virgin Islands, just east of St. Thomas along the Sir Francis Drake Channel. Its name comes from a pirate who claimed the island, and local stories speak of hidden gold and pirate ships hiding out in its calm bays. In 1750, Captain Owen Lloyd arrived here with 55 chests of silver dollars, three large chests of silver plates and wrought silver, plus indigo, tobacco, animal hides, and furs — all stolen from the Spanish galleon Nuestra Señora de Guadalupe. The cargo was valued at $200,000 at the time, equivalent to tens of millions today.

Lloyd left three crew members behind to finish burying and guarding the treasure. They weren’t discreet. Residents of Tortola swarmed Norman Island to dig up the loot, and the pirates were eventually captured and jailed. Only a small portion of the treasure was ever recovered. In the 1900s, a group of English treasure hunters formed the “Norman Island Treasure Company” and used large charges of gunpowder to blast holes in the island — they found nothing. Their activities inspired Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel Treasure Island.

Rumor has it that a descendant of a poor local family named Creque found one of the treasure chests in a cave on Norman Island during a storm. The Creque family later became significant landowners on St. Thomas and St. John, with no other explanation for their newfound wealth. Today, Creque’s Alley is a well-known shopping area in downtown Charlotte Amalie on St. Thomas. Heading into Treasure Point reframed the day — it’s the spot with sweeping vistas where pirates supposedly stashed their loot, and you can hike there on a guided tour.

Note: Norman Island has no hotels or resorts. Most visitors base themselves on Tortola or nearby islands, or stay on a chartered yacht. The best time to visit is December to April, when skies are sunny, seas are calm, and temperatures are warm.

The Caves & Treasure Point: Pirate Hideouts Above and Below

Just off Norman Island’s coastline, a series of sea grottos called The Caves punch into the island’s cliffs. Some of these underwater caves reach depths of up to 40 feet, and pirates once used them as hideouts while evading patrols in the Sir Francis Drake Channel. Today, they’re one of the top snorkeling and diving spots in the BVI, with coral reefs and schools of fish filling the clear blue water.

The Caves are accessible by kayak, paddleboard, or small boat, and guided tours often combine a visit here with a stop at Treasure Point. The water is calm enough for beginner snorkelers, and the cave openings create dramatic light patterns on the water inside. If you’re traveling with kids who are new to snorkeling, this is a gentle introduction — the shallow sections let them get comfortable before venturing deeper.

Treasure Point sits on the higher ground of Norman Island and offers sweeping views of the Sir Francis Drake Channel. It’s rumored to be one of the specific hiding places where pirates stashed their loot. The hike up is short but rocky, so wear sturdy sandals or water shoes. A guided tour makes sense here — local guides know which paths are safe and can point out the caves below from the vantage point.

From the caves and viewpoints of Norman Island, the next stop is Tortola, where a parallel chapter of the treasure story unfolded.

Tortola: The Missing Chests and the Governor’s Search

Not all of Lloyd’s treasure stayed on Norman Island. Some of it was buried on Tortola, the largest of the British Virgin Islands and the territory’s cultural and commercial hub. After the word got out that pirates had stashed silver on Tortola, Gilbert Fleming — the acting Lieutenant General of the Leeward Islands — commissioned two companies of soldiers to search the island and Norman Island. A proclamation stated that the treasure would be returned to Spain, with the finder receiving a one-third share as a finder’s fee.

Some treasure was found on Tortola, but only a portion of what the cargo manifest listed. The rest has never been recovered. For families based on Tortola, the practical advantage is clear: you can take day trips to Norman Island, The Caves, and other treasure sites without needing to move accommodations. The island has ferry connections to St. Thomas and the other BVI islands, plus rental cars and taxis for getting around.

If your kids are already hooked on the pirate story, Tortola gives you a chance to explore the treasure angle without being on a boat all day. You can visit the historical sites in Road Town, talk to local guides about the Creque family story, and plan your Norman Island day trip from a solid base. The island also has grocery stores, pharmacies, and a hospital — useful when traveling with children.

Dead Chest Island & Sandy Spit: Pirate Lore and Secluded Shores

Beyond the main treasure sites, the BVI holds smaller islands with their own pirate connections. Dead Chest Island is named after a pirate legend — according to local lore, Blackbeard marooned mutineers here with nothing but a dead man’s chest of rum. Sandy Spit is a tiny sandbar that offers the kind of deserted-island experience that pirate stories are made of. Neither island has facilities, and both are best visited as part of a chartered boat tour.

These spots are less about finding treasure and more about experiencing the landscape that pirates once used for shelter and seclusion. The water around Dead Chest Island is clear and calm, good for snorkeling, while Sandy Spit is more of a photo stop and beachcombing break. If you’re short on time, prioritize Norman Island and The Caves over these two — but if you have a full day on the water, they add a layer of pirate atmosphere that kids will love.

Getting Around the BVI’s Treasure Sites

The single biggest practical challenge of visiting these treasure locations is that none of them are connected by road. Norman Island, The Caves, Dead Chest Island, and Sandy Spit are all reachable only by private boat, ferry, or yacht charter. Tortola is the exception — it has roads, rental cars, and hotels — but even getting to Tortola requires a flight into St. Thomas followed by a ferry or a direct flight to Terrance B. Lettsome International Airport on Beef Island.

The dry season from December to April is the best time to visit. You’ll get sunny skies, warm temperatures, calm seas, and ideal conditions for sailing, snorkeling, and hiking. Outside this window, you may encounter rougher seas and more rain, which can make boat trips less comfortable — especially with young children.

Reef Protection and Local Customs

The coral reefs around Norman Island and The Caves are fragile and protected. Follow reef protection rules: don’t touch or stand on coral, use reef-safe sunscreen, and avoid dropping anchor directly on reef beds. Local guides take these rules seriously, and fines can apply. Respect local customs, protect marine life, and keep a close eye on children near rocky areas — the same rocks that made good pirate hideouts can be slippery and sharp.

What to Pack for a Treasure-Hunting Day on the Water

A day spent hopping between treasure sites means being on or near the water for five to seven hours. Pack reef-safe sunscreen, rash guards, water shoes, snorkel gear (tours provide it, but bringing your own ensures a good fit for kids), plenty of drinking water, snacks, and a dry bag for electronics. A lightweight drone can capture the coastline and cave openings from above, though check local regulations before flying. If you’re planning to document the trip, an action camera with a waterproof housing is more practical than a phone for underwater shots at The Caves.

Heads up: some links here are affiliate links — costs you nothing extra. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Before You Go — British Virgin Islands Treasure Sites

Can you actually find treasure on Norman Island today?

Technically, yes — the treasure was never fully recovered. But you’re not likely to stumble on a chest of silver on a family day trip. The real value is in experiencing the same caves and coves where pirates hid.

The BVI government does not issue treasure-hunting permits for casual visitors. Stick to snorkeling, hiking, and guided tours. If you want the thrill of a treasure hunt, some tour operators offer pirate-themed excursions for kids that include maps and mock treasure finds.

Do you need a boat to visit every site?

Yes, except for Tortola. Norman Island, The Caves, Dead Chest Island, and Sandy Spit are all water-access only. Ferry services run from Tortola to Norman Island, but schedules are limited. A chartered day trip is the most reliable way to hit multiple spots.

If you’re not comfortable renting a boat, book a guided tour from Tortola or St. Thomas. The cost includes transport, a guide, and often lunch — worth it for families who prefer not to navigate unfamiliar channels.

Is the water safe for kids at The Caves?

Yes, the shallow sections are beginner-friendly. The Caves have calm entry points, and many families bring children as young as five or six to snorkel here. Supervise kids near the cave walls and rocky edges.

If your child is new to snorkeling, practice in the calm coves of Norman Island first. The water is clear, the current is mild, and the fish are plentiful — a low-pressure introduction to snorkeling.

What’s the biggest downside of visiting these treasure sites?

Access is the main friction point. You can’t drive to any of the treasure locations except Tortola, and ferry schedules are limited. If you’re staying on Tortola, you’ll need to budget a full day for a Norman Island trip.

The second downside is the heat and sun exposure. These islands have limited shade, and the Caribbean sun is intense even on cloudy days. Bring more water and sun protection than you think you’ll need.

When is the worst time to visit?

September and October are the peak of hurricane season. Many boat tours and ferries reduce schedules, and the seas can be rough. Even if a storm isn’t forming, the weather is more unpredictable.

If you’re planning a treasure-themed trip, stick to December through April. You’ll get the calmest seas, the most reliable tour schedules, and the best conditions for snorkeling at The Caves.

Where the Pirates Left Their Mark

The treasure story of the BVI isn’t a myth — it’s a documented heist with a paper trail, a governor’s search party, and a family fortune that appeared overnight. What makes it worth chasing isn’t the silver still buried somewhere in a cave on Norman Island. It’s the fact that you can float in the same grottos, hike the same ridges, and anchor in the same calm coves that pirates used three centuries ago, and the water hasn’t changed a bit. If you’re looking for a way to make a family trip to the BVI feel like an adventure rather than just another beach vacation, the pirate trail gives you a reason to explore deeper. Read more about the BVI’s shipwreck history and how to visit them.

References

National Geographic. “Pirates.” National Geographic, n.d. ↗

History.com Editors. “Pirate Treasure Lost and Found.” History.com, n.d. ↗

BVI Tourism. “Home.” BVI Tourism, n.d. ↗

British Virgin Villas. “Norman Island.” British Virgin Villas, n.d. ↗

If the treasure trail has you thinking about other ways to explore the BVI’s hidden corners, check out our guide to secret spots across the islands, or see where the best anchorages and uninhabited islands can take you. For photographers, capturing the BVI’s coastline from the water is its own kind of treasure hunt.