The 2024 crawfish season was the best ever, with an average price of $12 per pound.
— Keith Carroll, President, National Fisheries Association
August through March is crawfish season in the Bahamas, and if you’re planning a trip to Nassau during those months, you’ve picked the right window. The 2024 season set records — the National Fisheries Association called it the best ever, with RBDF patrols cutting poaching and divers bringing in hauls that sometimes filled their anchors to capacity. For anyone who loves spiny lobster, that translates to fresh, local crawfish on menus across the island at prices that make sense.
You’ll find crawfish season dinners at everything from a Friday-night fish fry to a 250-year-old colonial mansion. The trick is matching the setting to your evening — Arawak Cay for messy, lively plates with the locals, Blue Marlin for a sunset harbour view, Graycliff when the occasion calls for a wine list of 250,000 bottles, and The Grill Hut when you need something reliable and fast steps from the cruise port.
Foodies
Families
Cruise passengers
Each spot below is within a short ride of the cruise port, so you can go from ship to dinner table without losing your evening. Here’s where to book your table — and what to order when you get there.
| Restaurant | Best For | Price Range | From Cruise Port | Crawfish Season Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arawak Cay Fish Fry | Conch salad, fried snapper, cracked conch | $ | 5-min taxi | Friday evenings offer the full local scene |
| Blue Marlin Restaurant | Cold bar, harbour views, elevated seafood | $$–$$$ | 7-min walk | Lobster in season; grilled fish changes daily |
| Graycliff Restaurant | Fine dining, wine, special occasions | $$$$ | 10-min taxi | Bahamian ingredients with fine-dining treatment |
| The Grill Hut | Conch fritters, grilled snapper, quick lunch | $–$$ | Steps away | Reliable late-afternoon spot; jerk chicken too |
Arawak Cay Fish Fry — Friday Night with the Locals
Friday evening at Arawak Cay is where Nassuvians bring their families. The music from competing sound systems fills the air, and the smell of frying fish and salt water hits you before you sit down. If your crew is anything like ours, Lily and Ethan would be drawn to the music while you grab a tray of cracked conch — whole conch pounded, battered, and fried, with more texture than the fritter version.
Arawak Cay Fish Fry on a Friday evening — arrive by 6:30 p.m. to get a table before the real crowd rolls in. The conch salad should be made to order; if it’s sitting pre-made, ask them to make a fresh batch.
For a deeper look at how locals eat around Nassau, this guide to Nassau’s authentic food scene covers more hidden spots beyond the fish fry.
Blue Marlin Restaurant — Harbour Views and a Serious Cold Bar
Blue Marlin sits a short walk from the cruise port, which makes it an easy choice if you want something between a fish fry and a white-tablecloth evening. The cold bar is the draw — fresh and lightly cured Bahamian seafood paired with a cocktail program that takes itself seriously. The grilled fish changes daily depending on what’s fresh, and when crawfish is in season, it shows up on the menu alongside the coconut shrimp and conch fritters.
Sunset visits are particularly worthwhile. The terrace overlooks Nassau Harbour, and the evening light on the water turns a good meal into a memorable one. Book a table on their official site to secure a harbour-side spot.
Blue Marlin Restaurant at sunset — arrive by 5 p.m. for a terrace table. The cold bar fills fast on weekends, and the kitchen closes at 4pm weekdays, 6pm weekends, so plan accordingly.
Graycliff Restaurant — Fine Dining in a Colonial Mansion
Graycliff is the splurge option, and it earns every dollar. Housed in a 250-year-old Georgian colonial mansion, the restaurant’s wine cellar alone — more than 250,000 bottles — makes it worth a visit for serious oenophiles. The seafood menu takes Bahamian ingredients and treats them with a fine-dining sensibility, so the crawfish you’d find at Arawak Cay gets reimagined on a plate with precision and presentation.
This is not a quick dinner. Plan for a leisurely evening, and reserve well ahead. If you’re celebrating something — anniversary, birthday, or just making it to Nassau — this is the place. For more on elevated Bahamian dining, this guide to unique dining experiences in the Bahamas has other options worth considering.
The Grill Hut — Steps from the Ship, Reliable Every Time
The Grill Hut is the kind of place you walk past and smell before you see. It’s steps from the cruise port, making it the easiest option on this list for anyone on a tight schedule. The conch fritters are reliably good, and the grilled snapper is fresh — order whichever is listed as the catch of the day. If someone in your group wants a break from seafood, the jerk chicken holds its own.
It opens at 2 p.m. daily, which makes it a strong late-afternoon option when you’ve spent the morning onshore and need something quick before heading back to the ship. Check their current hours on their site before walking over.
Ordering Bahamian Seafood — A Quick Guide
Knowing what to order and when makes the difference between a good meal and a great one. Crawfish season runs August through March, but the rest of the seafood menu has its own rules too.
Always order it made to order — never pre-made. If it’s sitting in a bowl, ask when it was made. Fresh conch salad has a bright, clean texture that fades fast once it sits.
Cracked conch is whole conch pounded, battered, and fried — more texture, more chew. Conch fritters are chopped conch in batter, lighter and easier to share. If you want the full conch experience, go cracked.
Grouper is meatier and milder. Snapper has more flavour. Order whichever is listed as the catch of the day — that’s what came in fresh that morning.
Bahamian spiny lobster (crawfish) is in season August through March. Outside that window, ask if the lobster on the menu is local or imported. If it’s imported, it won’t taste the same.
Crawfish season runs August to the end of March. If you’re visiting between April and July, most local crawfish is off-limits — divers are banned from using compressors during that window, which limits the catch. Ask before you order.
Before You Go — Crawfish Season in the Bahamas
Is crawfish the same as lobster in the Bahamas?
Yes — Bahamian “crawfish” is spiny lobster. It’s in season from August through March, which is the same window as the local lobster season.
If you see “lobster” on a menu outside that window, ask whether it’s local or imported. The local stuff is what makes the season special.
What’s the average price for crawfish in season?
The 2024 season averaged $12 per pound, according to the National Fisheries Association. That’s a strong price for high-quality spiny lobster.
Prices at restaurants will be higher than the dock price, but the value is still good compared to imported lobster.
Can I find crawfish dinners outside Nassau?
This guide focuses on Nassau restaurants within reach of the cruise port, but crawfish is available across the islands during season.
If you’re staying on another island, ask at local fish fries and dockside restaurants — the catch comes in daily, and the best crawfish often doesn’t make it to a printed menu.
What’s the best night for a crawfish dinner?
Friday evening at Arawak Cay Fish Fry is the classic move — the atmosphere peaks with families, music, and the smell of frying fish. For a quieter evening, Blue Marlin at sunset is hard to beat.
Graycliff requires a reservation and a budget, but it’s worth it for a special occasion. The Grill Hut works any day it’s open.
Are there downsides to visiting during crawfish season?
The season runs through March, which overlaps with the tail end of winter weather. Some outdoor seating at places like Arawak Cay can be breezy.
Also, the compressor ban from March to August means divers can’t use equipment that helps them stay down longer — that can affect supply in the shoulder months.
The Season You Came For
August through March is the window when Bahamian crawfish is at its best, and the restaurants in Nassau make the most of it — from the Friday-night chaos of Arawak Cay to the quiet terrace at Blue Marlin. You don’t need a rental car or a long drive to find a great dinner; most of these spots are within a 10-minute ride of the port, and one is steps away. If you’re still weighing which part of Nassau to base yourself in, this guide to farm-to-table Bahamian dining can help you plan your meals around the freshest local ingredients.
References
Things to Do in Bahama. “Best Seafood Restaurants in Nassau 2026.” 2025. ↗
Carroll, Keith. “Best Crawfish Season Ever, Says NFA President.” The Nassau Guardian, 2024. ↗
The seafood scene in Nassau runs deeper than one meal. If you’ve got room for another dinner, the epicurean experiences beyond the beach guide covers more high-end options, while the low tide tacos post is perfect for a casual lunch. For something sweet afterward, Bahamian desserts you probably haven’t tried rounds out the evening nicely.
Explore Places to Stay in the Bahamas
Feel free to zoom in and out of the map to explore the area and find the best place to stay for your trip.