Island
Hopper
GUIDES

Where to Find the Best Crawfish Season Dinners in the Bahamas

Keith Carroll, president of the National Fisheries Association, calls the current crawfish season “the best season ever for crawfishing,” with prices holding at $12 per pound all season. The season runs August 1 to March 31, and that’s the window for eating fresh local crawfish—Caribbean spiny lobster—at fish fries across the Bahamas. This article visitors want where to find the best crawfish dinners within that window, from the most accessible spots in Nassau to the fishery centres the boats land their catch.

The single spot to start is the Fish Fry at Arawak Nassau, a strip brightly painted food on West Bay Street about ten minutes by taxi from the cruise terminal. It’s locals and alike for conch, fried, and—during crawfish—lobster prepared a half-dozen ways.

“It’s the best season ever for crawfishing,” says Keith Carroll, president of the National Fisheries Association, with prices averaging $12 per pound throughout the season.

Emily’s Take

For most visitors, the Fish Fry at Arawak Cay is the best bet: it’s close to the cruise port, has dozens of stalls, and serves crawfish in season. If you have time to venture Spanish Wells is the heart the fishery, but you’ll need to arrange transport. Skip ordering crawfish between April and July—the season is closed and enforced.

Best for
Foodie travelers
Cruise passengers
Island hoppers

In Nassau, the Fish Fry at Arawak Cay Is Your Best Bet

Arawak Cay, built in 1969 from sand from the harbour, is a row of food shacks painted in bright colours along West Bay Street. The strip known as the Fish Fry, and it’s the most concentrated dose of Bahamian cooking in one stop. During crawfish season, dozens of stalls serve lobster alongside the usual conch and fried fish.

Twin Brothers is one of the best-known shacks here, famous for its conch salad mixed to order and a busy bar. Goldie’s Conch House—run by Kirkwood “Goldie” Evans, long called the King of Conch—is a fixture for cracked conch and sky juice. On weekends, the open stage fills up with music, making the Fish Fry as much a night out as a dinner stop.

The Fish Fry at Arawak Cay is about ten minutes by taxi from the cruise terminal, or a cheap ride on local jitney buses. It’s the easiest place for a visitor to try Bahamian crawfish without leaving New Providence.

Spanish Wells, Andros, and the Berry Islands: Where the Catch Comes From

The crawfish fishery is centred on three island areas: Spanish Wells, Andros, and the Berry Islands. Spanish Wells in particular built its prosperity on the crawfish catch—the island’s fleet lands much of the national supply. If you’re island-hopping and want to eat crawfish close to the source, these are the places where the boats land their catch.

E
If you only have a few days in the Bahamas, I’d skip the trip to Spanish Wells and stick with the Fish Fry in Nassau—the crawfish is just as good and you won’t spend half a day getting there and back.
— Emily Carter

Fish fries and family island restaurants do it best here, serving crawfish cracked, curried, or grilled. The catch is as fresh as it gets since the boats are landing it nearby.

What to Order: Cracked, Curried, and Grilled

Bahamian crawfish shows on the plate in a few ways. Cracked crawfish is the tail meat pounded tender, battered, fried, served with hot sauce. Curried crawfish is a heartier family island version. You’ll also find it simply grilled with butter, or minced into a salad with peppers and seasoning.

What you’re eating is the Caribbean spiny lobster, a clawless species taken from the shallow banks around the islands.

Practical Notes for Crawfish Season

Know the Season

Crawfish season runs from August 1 to March 31. From April through July, the fishery is closed to let the population breed, and the ban is enforced. If you see lobster on a menu during those months, something is wrong—don’t order it.

Understand the Price

Fishermen are getting $12 per pound for crawfish this season, and that price has held steady. At restaurants, expect to pay more than the dockside price—prices are high and usually by weight, so agree on the cost before ordering. On the Family Islands, the price may be lower because seafood houses have more bargaining power in a restricted market.

What to Avoid

Don’t order crawfish between April and July. Undersized lobster is also illegal, so if the portion looks small, that’s a red flag. Prices are lowest early in the season, so August and September are the best months for value.

Before You Go: Eating Crawfish in the Bahamas

Is Bahamian crawfish the same as lobster?

Yes—what the Bahamas calls crawfish is the Caribbean spiny lobster, a clawless species that lives on the shallow banks around the islands. It’s from the same family as lobster but lacks the large claws of the Maine variety, so the tail is the main attraction.

How do I get to the Fish Fry from the cruise port?

The Fish Fry at Arawak Cay is about ten minutes by taxi from the cruise terminal in Nassau. You can also take a cheap ride on local jitney buses that run along West Bay Street.

What should I drink with my crawfish dinner?

At the Fish Fry, the local favourite is sky juice—coconut water mixed with gin and condensed milk, dusted with nutmeg. For a non-alcoholic, try switcha, a Bahamian lemonade made from fresh lime or sour orange. If you want rum, a Goombay Smash or Bahama Mama are classic island cocktails.

Where to Eat Crawfish in the Bahamas: Your Best Bets

Here’s how to decide based on your situation:

  • If you’re on a cruise stop in Nassau, head to the Fish Fry at Arawak Cay—it’s ten minutes from the port and has dozens of stalls serving crawfish in season.
  • If you’re island-hopping and want to eat at the source, make for Spanish Wells, where the crawfish fleet lands much of the national catch.
  • If you’re visiting between April and July, skip fresh crawfish entirely—the season is closed and enforced.
  • If you want the best value, go early in the season (August or September) when prices are lowest.

References

Kemp, Youri. “Crawfish Season One of the Best at $12 Per Pound.” The Nassau Guardian, 2024. ↗

Kemp, Youri. “Best Crawfish Season Ever Says NFA President.” The Nassau Guardian, 2025. ↗

Bahamas Ministry of Tourism. “Fish Fry at Arawak Cay.” Bahamas.com. ↗

Explore Places to Stay in the Bahamas

Feel free to zoom in and out of the map to explore the area and find the best place to stay for your trip.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Emily Carter

I’m Emily Carter, a travel writer who’s on the road most of the year—sometimes with my husband Michael and our kids, Lily and Ethan, and other times traveling solo so I can focus closely on one place. When you travel with me through my writing, you’ll notice I move slowly, walking local streets, stopping at markets, and paying attention to how a place really feels once you’re there. When I’m traveling with my family, I’m always thinking about what will work well for you if you have kids, and what often gets overlooked. When I’m on my own, I spend more time in neighborhoods, along coastal paths, or in historic areas where daily life unfolds naturally. I focus on practical details, everyday food, and real experiences, so you know what you’ll actually see, hear, and experience when you arrive.

And oh, I may earn a small commission from affiliate links, which helps support the site at no extra cost to you. Thanks for the support!

Leave a Reply