Scrape the saw. Beat the drum. Now you have music — and a story that runs from Cat Island to the modern era.
Rake-and-scrape music emerged on Cat Island in the 1800s as a hybrid of European melody and African rhythm, using a carpenter’s saw, a pork barrel drum, and a concertina.
Rake-and-scrape is the foundational folk sound of The Bahamas — a rhythmic, raspy style born from limited resources. But it’s not the only Bahamian music. Goombay, Junkanoo, and rhyming spirituals each have distinct origins and social roles. Rake-and-scrape remains a living heritage, most visible on Cat Island and at cultural festivals, not in Nassau resort shows.
| Variant | Origin | Core Instruments | Social Context | Status Today |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rake-and-Scrape | Cat Island, 1800s | Carpenter’s saw, goombay drum, concertina | Quadrille, maypole, village dances | Preserved, performed at festivals |
| Goombay | Throughout The Bahamas, 1920s–1970s | Piano, horns, guitar, banjo, drum | Ballrooms, hotel socials | Historical, influential |
| Junkanoo | Throughout The Bahamas | Cowbells, drums, horns, whistles | Boxing Day, New Year’s Day parade | National celebration, dominant |
| Rhyming Spiritual | Baptist churches, Afro-Bahamian communities | Voice (rhymer, bass, alto) | Church, wakes, concerts | Active in religious communities |
The Island That Invented a Sound
Cat Island in the 1800s was rural, isolated, and resourceful. The instruments that emerged there tell that story directly. A carpenter’s saw provided the scrape — a musician runs a metal file or piece of metal across its teeth for a rasping, rhythmic percussion. A pork barrel with goatskin stretched over one end became the goombay drum, played with open hands to produce a warm, rolling pulse. And a concertina or accordion carried the melody, often adapted from European quadrille tunes.
The goombay drum sets a steady, rolling beat with open-hand strikes. The drum’s name comes from a Bantu word for “rhythm” and the drum itself — a linguistic marker of African heritage that survives in the music.
A metal file or piece of metal is dragged across the teeth of a carpenter’s saw. The saw acts as both percussion and noisemaker, producing a raspy metallic accent that cuts through the drum.
The concertina or accordion plays European dance tunes — quadrilles, waltzes, maypole melodies — but adapted to local rhythms and dance steps. The melody is simple, repetitive, and infectious.
Quadrille sets or maypole dancers move in response to the music. The dance is as structured as the music — a social event for the whole community, not a performance for an audience.
The dance connection is not incidental. Rake-and-scrape accompanied quadrille — a European square dance that Afro-Bahamian communities reshaped into something distinctly local — and maypole dances, which European settlers brought but which took on different movement styles in the Caribbean. The music was functional, not performative: you made it to dance to it.
What’s still debated among historians is how much the European vs. African elements dominate the fusion. Some accounts hold that the concertina tunes are almost pure European survivals, while the drumming and rhythmic conception are African. Others argue that the scrape — a percussive, non-melodic technique — has no clear European precedent and may represent an African-derived approach to rhythm. The question remains unresolved.
From Saw to Symphony — The Goombay Band
By the 1920s, rake-and-scrape bands began adding instruments. A piano appeared, then horns, guitars, banjos, and sometimes a wash tub with a string rigged as a modified bass violin. These expanded ensembles became known as Goombay bands, named after the drum but representing a fuller, more polished sound. This period lasted into the mid-1970s.
Blake Alphonso Higgs, known as “Blind Blake” (1915–1986), is widely regarded as the Father of Bahamian Music. He took the Goombay sound and gave it national reach, recording and touring with a repertoire that blended rake-and-scrape energy with more structured song forms. His music appears in the work of scholars and collectors who documented mid-20th-century Bahamian music.
The word “Goombay” itself carries contested origins. Some trace it to the Gambian word “gumbay” for a large drum. Others identify it as a Bantu word meaning “rhythm.” The spelling varies in The Bahamas, but the shared origin is broadly acknowledged. Goombay music also influenced religious music outside the established Anglican and Roman Catholic denominations — particularly in Baptist churches, where hymns were lined off line by line to the chorus, and the rhyming spiritual developed with three-part harmony led by a rhymer, a bass, and an alto.
The Rhythm That Took Over
If rake-and-scrape is the quiet ancestor, Junkanoo is the loud inheritor. Since the 1960s, Junkanoo evolved into a massive, rapid, cacophonous street parade where costumed groups compete with cowbells, drums, horns, and whistles producing the now-famous “Kalik, Kalikin’ kalik” sound. It’s the predominant musical form in The Bahamas today.
Junkanoo takes place on Boxing Day (December 26) and New Year’s Day. Groups prepare all year, designing elaborate costumes and rehearsing intricate choreography. The goombay drum is still the rhythmic anchor, but it’s buried under layers of amplified noise. The spectacle has become the national symbol of Bahamian identity.
But rake-and-scrape hasn’t disappeared. It’s preserved in museums, at cultural festivals, and most importantly on Cat Island, where the tradition never fully gave way to Junkanoo. The National Museum of The Bahamas and the Pompey Museum in Exuma feature exhibits on the music’s history. Cordell Thompson, Exuma historian and Pompey Center director, compiled much of the documentation used in this article, drawing on research from The New York Times and his own three decades with the Bahamas Ministry of Tourism.
Three Traditions, One Island Nation
How the sounds compare
| Aspect | Rake-and-Scrape | Goombay | Junkanoo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Instruments | Saw, goombay drum, concertina | Piano, horns, guitar, banjo, drum | Cowbells, drums, horns, whistles |
| Volume and style | Raspy, rolling, intimate | Fuller, danceable, structured | Loud, rapid, cacophonous |
| Occasion | Quadrille, maypole, village dance | Ballroom, hotel social | National parade, competition |
| Current presence | Heritage events, Cat Island festivals | Historical influence | Dominant pop culture |
Insider versus outsider understanding
| Aspect | Insider view | Outsider misconception |
|---|---|---|
| “Island music” | Several distinct traditions exist | One homogenous “Bahamian sound” |
| Rake-and-scrape | Proud, specific heritage | “Just scraping a saw” — misses the fusion |
| Junkanoo | Competitive, structured art form | “Just a noisy parade” — misses the history |
| Goombay | Bridge between eras | Unknown to most tourists |
Don’t conflate rake-and-scrape with Junkanoo. They share a common ancestor in the goombay drum and African rhythmic traditions, but they’re distinct in instrumentation, social context, and sound. Rake-and-scrape is not “old Junkanoo” — it’s a different tradition that continues alongside Junkanoo. Also, don’t assume you’ll hear it on every corner. It’s most reliably found at Cat Island festivals, not in Nassau resort entertainment.
If you want to hear real rake-and-scrape, plan a trip around Cat Island’s homecoming festival. Ask for a “rake-and-scrape band” specifically — not just “local music.” The phrase tells musicians you know what to look for, and you’ll likely get directed to the most authentic performance.
- Rake-and-scrape is the foundational folk music of The Bahamas, originating on Cat Island in the 1800s as a fusion of European melody and African rhythm.
- The three core instruments — carpenter’s saw, goombay drum, concertina — reflect a tradition of making music with available materials.
- Goombay music expanded rake-and-scrape into a fuller band sound, while Junkanoo evolved into a national spectacle. All three coexist today, serving different social functions.
- The music is still debated: origins of the scrape technique, the exact relationship between Goombay and rake-and-scrape, and the degree of African vs. European influence remain unresolved.
A quick heads up — some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through them, it costs you nothing extra but earns IslandHopperGuides a small commission. Honestly, that’s a big part of what funds the travel and research that goes into guides like this one. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases — and I really do appreciate the support.
Questions About Bahamian Folk Music
What does “rake and scrape” mean?
The name comes from the sound and motion of the saw. “Rake” refers to the action of scraping a metal file across the teeth of a carpenter’s saw. “Scrape” is the raspy sound it produces. Together, they describe the percussion technique that gives the music its signature texture.
Is rake-and-scrape the same as Goombay?
Not exactly. Rake-and-scrape is the older, stripped-down form (saw, drum, concertina). Goombay grew out of it in the 1920s–1970s, adding piano, horns, guitars, and banjos. Goombay is the “full band” version — but both rely on the same goombay drum rhythmic foundation.
Can I see rake-and-scrape performed today?
Yes, but mainly at cultural festivals, on Cat Island, and at heritage events. The National Museum of The Bahamas and the Pompey Museum in Exuma feature exhibits. It’s not a nightly show — you have to seek it out. To listen at home, search online for collections of Bahamian goombay and rake-and-scrape music.
What does the goombay drum look like?
It’s a barrel drum, traditionally a pork barrel with goatskin stretched over one end. The skin is held by a hoop and tightened with rope or wedges. It’s played with bare hands, producing a warm, open tone that’s neither as high-pitched as a conga nor as deep as a djembe. The drum is the rhythmic anchor of both rake-and-scrape and Junkanoo.
The Scrape That Connects Centuries
Rake-and-scrape is not a relic. It’s the sonic blueprint of The Bahamas — a reminder that culture is what you make with what you have. A carpenter’s saw, a barrel, and a borrowed European melody, reimagined through African rhythm. That story — of resourcefulness, fusion, and collective joy — is still audible every time a musician picks up a saw and a goombay drum. The tradition lives not because it was preserved in amber, but because people on Cat Island and beyond still choose to play it.
For more on how Bahamian sound evolved into the nation’s most visible celebration, read about Bahamian Junkanoo: Unmasking the History and Heartbeat of a National Celebration.
Sources and further reading
Cordell Thompson. “Bahamian Musical Traditions — From Goombay to the Music of Today.” Compiled for the Pompey Museum and Bahamas Ministry of Tourism. 🔗
Smithsonian Institution. “Caribbean Music: Roots and Traditions.” Smithsonian Folkways. 🔗
National Museum of The Bahamas. “Exhibitions: Goombay and Rake and Scrape.” 🔗
Related reading on IslandHopperGuides
Island Voices: Uncovering the Oral Traditions and Storytelling of The Bahamas — How spoken word traditions parallel the musical ones in preserving community memory.
From Lucayan Legacy to Modern Bahamas: Tracing Indigenous Roots — The deeper pre-colonial history that shaped all subsequent Bahamian culture.
Explore Places to Stay in the Bahamas
Feel free to zoom in and out of the map to explore the area and find the best place to stay for your trip.