From Slavery to Freedom: Understanding Cayman’s Emancipation History

The banner stretched across the road at Bodden Town’s western entrance read “Slavery be dead, we be free.” At the eastern end, another declared “De king hab set we free, rejoice.” When Captain Anthony Pack arrived days after reading the Emancipation Proclamation at Fort George, he found men, women and children waving flags, firing muskets, and dancing to fiddle music. Dr. Robert Thompson, who recorded the scene, called it “wild demonstrations of joy.” But that joy masked a harder truth: freedom had arrived without land, without homes, and without a single penny of compensation for the generations of unpaid labour that built the islands’ early economy. Cayman’s path from slavery to freedom was both exceptional and deeply compromised — and for 62 years, the islands stopped marking it altogether.

The question this guide explores is straightforward but has no simple answer: what really happened when slavery ended in the Cayman Islands, and why does the story matter differently today than it did a generation ago? Anyone curious about how small British colonies navigated the end of slavery — and how they remember it now — will find Cayman’s case instructive precisely because it breaks the regional mold.

These five moments span more than two centuries, and each reveals a different facet of how freedom was pursued, declared, lived, and remembered. The rest of this guide traces the thread that connects them.

The Proclamation at Fort George

On the afternoon of 3 May 1835, Captain Anthony Pack of the British West India Regiment stood at Fort George in George Town and read the Emancipation Proclamation aloud. Beside him stood Lord Sligo — Howe Peter Browne — the Governor of Jamaica and, by extension, the Cayman Islands. The document declared that all enslaved people in the islands were “absolutely and unconditionally free.” What made this declaration extraordinary was what it left out: the apprenticeship system.

Across the rest of the British Caribbean, the Slavery Abolition Act of 1833 had mandated a transition period during which formerly enslaved people would work as “apprenticed labourers” — a system historians have described as slavery by another name. But no apprenticeship programme had been registered in Britain for the Cayman Islands. When Pack read the proclamation, every apprentice in Cayman became immediately entitled to “unqualified enjoyment of their personal freedom.” Stuart Wilson, historic programmes manager of the National Trust, which owns and curates Fort George, has noted that this made Cayman’s emancipation history unique in the region.

The proclamation was read four times at Fort George that afternoon, on the hour between 3pm and 6pm. In 2025 and 2026, actors Adam Roberts (as Pack) and Adam Cockerill (as Sligo) re-enacted the scene for crowds — a ritual that had not been performed publicly for decades. The re-enactment is now an annual feature of Emancipation Day observances.

A Century of Slavery and the People Who Resisted It

The first enslaved people arrived in the Cayman Islands around 1730, brought from Jamaica to clear mahogany. Cotton plantations expanded in the late 18th century, and by 1802 Edward Corbett’s census recorded 545 slaves, the majority held by fewer than a dozen plantation owners. At emancipation in 1835, the enslaved population had grown to 985 — just under half the total population of the islands.

Two women from that era have recently moved from the margins of historical records to the centre of public memory. Elizabeth Jane Trusty bought her own freedom from slavery in 1809 — an act that required her to negotiate within a legal system designed to deny her personhood. Long Celia spoke openly about freedom and was sentenced to lashes for seditious words. Neither woman lived to see emancipation, but both are now recognized as figures who conceived of freedom before the law granted it. Brian Watler Jr., who helped develop the exhibition that features both women, has noted that many people know emancipation occurred in 1835 but few know it began earlier in the thoughts, actions, and resistance of enslaved persons.

Freedom Without Land

Emancipation Day was first observed in the Cayman Islands in 1835, soon after the proclamation. But the freedom declared that May morning came with conditions that shaped the next century. Lord Sligo told the newly freed people they now had “no person to feed you, no person to clothe you, no person to give you medical assistance if you are ill.” He urged them to show gratitude to Britain and to remain loyal to the king — and he advised those who had been mistreated to remember “probably you gave great provocation.”

Meanwhile, the British government paid more than £20 million in compensation to former slaveholders across its colonies. Cayman’s slaveholders claimed £44,764 and received roughly £19,700 — equivalent to about £1 million today. The formerly enslaved received nothing. The Accounts of Slave Compensation Claims for 19 Caribbean colonies detail these payments, and the names of Cayman’s claimants are recorded in the historical ledger.

After emancipation, many freed people continued working for their former masters or as day labourers. Some settled small holdings and survived by planting cassava, plantains, breadfruit, and yams, and by fishing. In Bodden Town, where the densest concentration of formerly enslaved people lived, social tension ran high. Proprietors sought cheap labour; former slaves sought genuine independence. A school funded by the Mico Charity opened but closed after its teacher, Malcolm, left — opposition from former slaveowners who objected to white and non-white students learning together had made his position untenable. Historian Michael Craton has described the decade following emancipation as a period of “unprecedented upheaval and change” in Cayman.

Reclaiming Emancipation Day

For more than a century, Cayman observed Emancipation Day on 1 August, the date the Slavery Abolition Act took effect across the British Empire. But in the 1960s, the holiday disappeared from the calendar, replaced by Constitution Day. For 62 years, there was no official public recognition of emancipation in the Cayman Islands.

That changed in 2024, when Premier Juliana O’Connor-Connolly announced the restoration of Emancipation Day as a public holiday, citing Cayman’s unique story. “The slaves in the Cayman Islands were the first to be truly free,” she said. Christopher Williams supported the restoration, stating: “We are not celebrating slavery, we are celebrating the tenacity of people who were once enslaved.” The first restored holiday was observed on 4 May 2024, and subsequent years have seen growing participation.

A quick heads up — some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through them, it costs you nothing extra but earns IslandHopperGuides a small commission. Honestly, that’s a big part of what funds the travel and research that goes into guides like this one. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases — and I really do appreciate the support.

In 2026, teacher Roy Murray delivered a free lecture titled “We had slaves here, sir?” at the Harquail Cultural Centre. Murray, who researched Caymanian slavery for his masters and PhD, brought coral stones from Bodden Town’s coastline to place near the Gate of No Return in Africa as a symbolic return. The lecture was part of a broader programme that included the exhibition and community discussions — evidence, as one observer put it, that Emancipation Day is increasingly understood as history being actively engaged with, not merely remembered.

Cayman in Caribbean Context

Cayman’s emancipation story stands out most sharply when placed beside the rest of the British Caribbean. The table below compares key dimensions of the transition from slavery to freedom.

Questions Readers Ask

Why was there no apprenticeship period in the Cayman Islands?

The Slavery Abolition Act of 1833 required a transition period of apprenticeship, but no programme had been registered in Britain specifically for the Cayman Islands. When Captain Pack read the proclamation, the apprentices in Cayman were therefore entitled to immediate and unconditional freedom. This was an administrative gap, not a deliberate policy of early liberation.

Did any enslaved people resist before emancipation?

Yes. Elizabeth Jane Trusty bought her own freedom in 1809, negotiating within the legal system to achieve what the law otherwise denied her. Long Celia spoke openly about freedom and was sentenced to lashes for seditious words. The exhibition at the Cayman Islands National Museum documents both women and argues that resistance began long before the 1835 proclamation.

Who received compensation when slavery ended?

Only former slaveholders received compensation — roughly £19,700 for Cayman’s claimants, part of the more than £20 million the British government paid across its colonies. The formerly enslaved received nothing. The Accounts of Slave Compensation Claims list the names and amounts paid to Cayman’s slaveholders.

Was slavery in the Cayman Islands really “milder” than elsewhere?

This claim is actively disputed. Some historians have described Cayman slavery as less harsh due to the smaller scale of plantation agriculture. Christopher Williams of UCCI argues this minimises oppression, stating “slavery is slavery is slavery.” The historical record shows forced labour, corporal punishment, and family separation. The question remains unresolved among scholars.

Why did Emancipation Day disappear from the calendar for 62 years?

The holiday was observed on 1 August until the 1960s, when it was replaced by Constitution Day. The change reflected a broader shift in how the islands chose to mark their identity — toward constitutional development and away from the legacy of slavery. Premier Juliana O’Connor-Connolly restored the holiday in 2024, citing Cayman’s unique emancipation story.

What the Return of Emancipation Day Reveals

The restoration of Emancipation Day in 2024 did not settle the debates around Cayman’s slavery history — it reopened them. The holiday’s 62-year absence was not an oversight; it reflected a deliberate choice about which stories the islands would tell about themselves. Its return reflects a different choice, one that foregrounds the tenacity of the enslaved rather than the benevolence of the empire that enslaved them. That shift is visible in the museum exhibitions that now centre figures like Trusty and Celia, in the re-enactments that draw crowds to Fort George, and in the coral stones Roy Murray carried from Bodden Town to the Gate of No Return. For a deeper look at how migration and movement have shaped Caymanian identity across generations, read Diaspora Stories: The Impact of Migration on Caymanian Culture.

Sources and further reading

Cayman Compass. “Emancipation Day observed in Cayman.” 2026. 🔗

Cayman Independent. “New exhibition explores emancipation through two Cayman women.” 2026. 🔗

Cayman Compass. “Freedom declared: Emancipation Proclamation echoes through the ages.” 2025. 🔗

Cayman Compass. “‘Slavery be dead, we be free’: The amazing true story of emancipation in Cayman.” 2024. 🔗

Related reading on IslandHopperGuides

Celebrating Caymanian Women: Stories of Strength, Leadership, and Tradition — profiles of Caymanian women whose lives and leadership shaped the islands, including historical figures from the emancipation era.

The Maritime Heritage of Cayman: Exploring Its Sailing and Seafaring History — how the sea shaped Caymanian life, including the fishing and turtling economies that freed people built after emancipation.