The Legacy of Columbus: Unpacking the Complex History of La Isabela
In January 1494, a priest celebrated the first Catholic Mass in the Americas on a remote bluff on Hispaniola’s north coast. The settlement hosting that Mass — La Isabela — was a ghost town within four years. Christopher Columbus founded La Isabela on January 2, 1494, during his second voyage, after finding the earlier La Navidad settlement destroyed and its Spanish occupants dead or missing. He chose a narrow, windswept patch of land at the confluence of two swift rivers, intending it as Spain’s main stronghold on Hispaniola and a launch point for further exploration westward. The settlement carried