Where to Find Benny Cake and Other Vanishing Bahamian Treats
Benny cake doesn’t look like much — a flat, sesame seed brittle that snaps cleanly in half. But one bite into that caramelized crunch and you’re tasting generations of Bahamian confectionary tradition. And it’s getting harder to find. Mortimer Candies, a Nassau institution on E Hill Street, holds a 4.5-star rating across 167 reviews — proof that old-fashioned candy-making still draws a crowd. Emily’s Take You’ll find Benny cake and other vanishing Bahamian treats at a handful of local shops and bakeries, but Mortimer Candies in Nassau is the most reliable spot. Go early — many bakeries sell out